Who Was Jimmy Hill? The Footballer Who Changed English Football
If you’re old enough to have watched football in the seventies and eighties, Jimmy Hill was impossible to miss. The chin, the voice, the opinions — he was everywhere. But to pin him down as just a TV pundit would be selling him short.
Hill’s story stretches from the pitch at Fulham to the boardrooms that changed players’ lives, to the commentary box that made him one of the most loved — and loathed — voices in the sport.
He was a man who seemed to invite strong opinions, and maybe that’s why he’s still talked about years after his death in 2015. Some saw him as a visionary, others as smug, but there’s no denying that modern football looks very different because of Jimmy Hill.
Who did Jimmy Hill play for?
Before the chin and before the “toe poke” insults, Jimmy Hill was a professional footballer. He started his career with Brentford in 1949, but it was at Fulham that he made his name.
He joined them in 1952, and over the next decade became a regular fixture at Craven Cottage, racking up more than 300 appearances and scoring 52 goals.
At first he was a forward, but he later dropped into midfield, and it was in Fulham’s famous 1959 promotion-winning side that he truly made his mark.
Hill wasn’t the most gifted footballer of his era, nobody would claim he was in the same league as a Tom Finney or a Stanley Matthews. However, he was clever, industrious, and had the kind of football brain that would later serve him well as a manager and pundit.
Playing alongside legends like Johnny Haynes, Hill experienced top-flight football at a time when the game was still very different: muddy pitches, heavy balls, and a strict wage cap that meant even the best players couldn’t earn more than £20 a week. And that injustice stuck with him.
Scrapping the maximum wage
In 1957, while still at Fulham, Hill became chairman of the Professional Footballers’ Association (PFA). It was a bold move for a serving player, but Hill had always been one to put his head above the parapet.
His biggest fight came against the maximum wage. For years, players in England could only earn a fixed amount, no matter how good they were. In practice, that meant footballers earned barely more than the average factory worker.
Hill thought it was a disgrace. He led the campaign to abolish the maximum wage, and in January 1961 the cap was finally scrapped. Almost immediately, Fulham’s Johnny Haynes became the first £100-a-week footballer, a symbolic moment in the history of the game.
That decision changed football forever. Without it, the modern millionaire footballer might never have existed. Whether you see that as a blessing or a curse, Jimmy Hill was the man who made it possible.
The Coventry years
When his playing days ended in 1961, Hill quickly moved into management. Coventry City took him on, and it was there that he unleashed his most radical ideas.
Hill rebranded the club from top to bottom, turning them into “The Sky Blues.”
He changed their kit to the now-iconic pale blue, introduced the “Sky Blue Song” on matchdays, and even oversaw innovations like the first electronic scoreboard in English football. Coventry, previously a fairly anonymous club, suddenly had an identity.
On the pitch, he delivered too, guiding them from the Third Division to the top flight within six years. Hill wasn’t just thinking about tactics, though.
He was modernising football, experimenting with pre-match entertainment, all-seater stands, and the kind of matchday polish that most clubs wouldn’t catch up with for years.
The broadcaster
For many fans, though, it wasn’t his playing or managerial career that defined him, but his years in front of the cameras. Hill became a mainstay on Match of the Day and ITV’s The Big Match, later anchoring coverage for both BBC and ITV across the seventies, eighties, and nineties.
His style was unmistakable. He was articulate, confident, and never short of an opinion.
To some, he was the voice of reason. To others, he was smug, biased, and irritating. The truth probably sat somewhere in the middle. But he knew his stuff, and he could argue his case better than most.
Why Scottish fans hated him
If you were a Scotland supporter, chances are you couldn’t stand Jimmy Hill. It wasn’t just one incident, though he gave them plenty of ammunition.
The biggest flashpoint came in 1982, when Scotland played Brazil at the World Cup. Dave Narey opened the scoring with a thunderous strike from distance — one of the best goals any Scottish player has ever scored at a World Cup.
Hill, sitting in the studio, described it as a “toe poke.” Whether he meant it light-heartedly or not, the damage was done.
Scottish fans felt it summed up Hill perfectly: dismissive of their players, patronising, and always giving England more respect than Scotland.
From then on, “Jimmy Hill” became a terrace chant, often delivered with venom. The song “We hate Jimmy Hill” became almost a staple at Scotland games, and his name was hurled as an insult for years.
The chin and the liar’s gesture
Of course, Jimmy Hill’s most recognisable feature was his jawline. His chin jutted so prominently that it became a national talking point. And out of it grew a strange little cultural habit: rubbing your chin to call someone a liar. The gesture became known as “a Jimmy Hill.”
For kids in playgrounds across Britain, that was how his name lived on — not through Fulham or Coventry or Match of the Day, but through a cheeky hand signal.
Hill himself took it in good humour, though it must have been a bit wearying to be mocked for your chin every time you walked down the street.
Jimmy Hill died
By the time Jimmy Hill stepped away from broadcasting in the late 1990s, he had been a fixture in football for half a century. He continued to work behind the scenes and was involved in everything from stadium safety to TV rights.
In later years, though, he suffered from Alzheimer’s disease, and in 2008 his family revealed his diagnosis. Hill lived quietly in Sussex until his death in December 2015 at the age of 87.
The tributes poured in. Fulham, Coventry, and the wider football world recognised his contribution. At Coventry’s new stadium, a statue of him had already been unveiled in 2011 — a fitting reminder of how much he had done for the club.
Broadcasters spoke of his influence on how football was shown on TV, while the PFA and players pointed out that without Hill, footballers’ wages might never have caught up with their true value.
Jimmy Hill’s Legacy
So what do we make of Jimmy Hill? Visionary reformer? Smug pundit? Football revolutionary? The truth is he was all of those things.
He played for Fulham, managed Coventry, scrapped the wage cap, transformed matchday experiences, and became the face of football on television.
He also wound up half the terraces in Britain, whether because of his chin, his comments about Scotland, or his perceived bias towards England.
What’s undeniable is that he mattered. Few people outside the pitch have had such an influence on how the game is played, watched, and even paid for.
Football today, with its superstars on astronomical wages, its wall-to-wall TV coverage, and its slick matchday experiences, owes more than a little to Jimmy Hill. And whether you loved him or loathed him, you’d probably agree — it just wouldn’t have been the same without him.