From Pundit to the EFL: How Robbie Savage Became Peterborough Manager
For years, Robbie Savage was one of those football figures people thought they already understood. The hair, the tackles, the arguing, the phone-ins, the punditry.
What nobody really expected was for Savage to build a proper managerial career.
The Welshman has now been appointed Peterborough United manager, leaving Forest Green Rovers for his first job in the Football League. It would be easy to dismiss it as another high-profile gamble, but his record says otherwise.
Savage won the Northern Premier League with Macclesfield on 109 points, then took Forest Green into the National League play-offs.
With experience stretching from Manchester United’s academy and the Premier League to rebuilding in non-league, there is more footballing depth to this appointment than first meets the eye.
Robbie Savage Never Planned to Become a Manager
Savage’s route into management was hardly conventional. When Macclesfield Town were wound up in 2020, businessman Robert Smethurst bought the club’s assets and created Macclesfield FC.
Savage joined as director of football and shareholder, helping with a rebuild that started in the ninth tier. He was involved as the new club climbed the pyramid, but stayed out of the dugout until 2024.
That changed after Macclesfield lost the Northern Premier League play-off final to Marine. Michael Clegg left soon afterwards and Savage stepped in.
Suddenly, the bloke from 606 was picking the team.
Macclesfield Changed the Conversation
His first full season could hardly have gone better.
Macclesfield won the 2024/25 Northern Premier League Premier Division with 109 points and 109 goals, finishing 26 points clear and sealing promotion with six games remaining.
They did it playing the way Savage wanted. Macclesfield pressed high, attacked quickly and generally tried to make games uncomfortable rather than protect what they had.
Danny Elliott scored 41 goals in all competitions, and the Silkmen finished with 12 straight victories.
That season changed the conversation around Savage. Whatever people thought of his television career, he had just built a team that completely dominated its division.
The Players Bought Into Him
The reaction from the players was just as useful in understanding why it worked.
Danny Elliott said Savage was very different from how people might perceive him, while D’Mani Mellor said simply that he understood the players.
That counts for plenty at that level. Former Premier League players can walk into non-league dressing rooms with impressive CVs, but Saturday-Tuesday schedules, heavy pitches and players balancing very different careers quickly expose anyone who cannot connect with a group.
Savage appeared to manage through energy, standards and relationships. His players bought into it, and the results followed.
Departing Macclesfield
Savage left for Forest Green in the summer of 2025, and the departure was not universally popular.
He had been involved with Macclesfield FC from almost the beginning, so this was more than a manager simply taking another job. Owner Robert Smethurst admitted the speed of the departure hurt, while Savage later accepted that he had underestimated the reaction from supporters.
From a managerial point of view, though, the move made sense. Macclesfield was a club Savage had helped build. Forest Green gave him the chance to prove he could walk into somebody else’s dressing room, under somebody else’s ownership, and make it work there too.
A Tougher Job at Forest Green
Forest Green were trying to return to the Football League after relegation and came with a very different level of expectation.
Savage again wanted aggressive football, pressing, a high line and more opportunities for younger players. This time there was no procession. Forest Green finished seventh in the National League and reached the play-offs, where they were beaten by Boreham Wood.
It was not another promotion, but Savage had stepped up a level, moved away from familiar surroundings and kept Forest Green competitive. He also showed some realism about where he stood, admitting during his time there that he was nowhere near ready for jobs in the Championship, Premier League or with Wales.
From Pundit to Football League Manager
For the last couple of years, Savage has managed to keep one foot in both worlds.
Even while taking charge of Macclesfield and Forest Green, he was still appearing on television and radio. That crossover was part of the reason he found himself back around Macclesfield during their remarkable FA Cup run, watching the club he had helped rebuild beat Crystal Palace in one of the biggest shocks in the competition’s history.
At non-league level, that balance was just about workable.
Peterborough is different.
This is a full-time Football League job at a club already fighting near the bottom of League One. Supporters will expect the manager to be completely locked into training, recruitment, recovery and the next match.
If Posh are preparing for a relegation six-pointer, fans are not going to be too impressed seeing their gaffer on the other side of the country doing punditry the night before.
Whether Savage gives media work up completely remains to be seen, but this feels like the point where management has to become the main job rather than something running alongside it.
Why MacAnthony Went for Savage
Peterborough have never really been built for safety-first football. Their better sides have attacked, trusted younger players and backed themselves to develop talent rather than fill the squad with experienced names just because they know the division.
That suits Savage. His Macclesfield and Forest Green sides wanted to press high, play forward and take risks, while he has consistently backed younger players.
There are players at Peterborough he should enjoy working with. Harry Leonard is still only 22, scored 17 goals last season and looks exactly the sort of forward Posh would expect a manager to improve rather than simply replace.
The personalities line up too. MacAnthony has spent years saying exactly what he thinks about Peterborough, and Savage has never exactly struggled in that department.
The bigger question is what happens if Posh are still down there in January. Savage has inherited this squad rather than built it, so the winter window may tell us how strongly MacAnthony is prepared to back his appointment.
Savage Compared With Other Former Players
Former Premier League players moving into management is nothing new, but Savage has taken a less glamorous route than most.
Michael Carrick went from Manchester United’s coaching staff into Middlesbrough and is now back at Old Trafford. Craig Bellamy built his reputation through coaching before taking charge of Wales.
Savage started in non-league and had to make his case there.
You could argue that, relative to the level and resources he has worked with, his CV is already pretty strong. He has won a league title, taken another side into the play-offs and developed a clear way of playing along the way.
That does not put him ahead of Carrick or Bellamy outright, but it does make his rise through management much harder to dismiss.
Savage Has Always Had a Point to Prove
Savage went back to his playing career when discussing the doubts around his appointment.
He came through Manchester United’s Class of ’92 generation, training alongside David Beckham, Paul Scholes, Ryan Giggs, Nicky Butt and the Neville brothers, but never made a first-team appearance.
That shaped the rest of his career. Savage had to leave United, rebuild elsewhere and scrap for everything he got.
At Leicester he became an important part of Martin O’Neill’s side before going on to play for Birmingham, Blackburn and Derby, as well as winning 39 caps for Wales.
He was never the most gifted player in that United youth group, but he still built a long Premier League career.
That same chip on the shoulder has followed him into management.
There are still plenty of people who see the pundit before the manager. Macclesfield gave him an answer to that. Forest Green gave him another.
Peterborough is where he gets to answer it in the Football League.